Not everyone needs the latest flagship phone. In fact, savvy shoppers often look a generation or two back to get excellent performance at a fraction of the cost. This philosophy is gaining even more traction in 2026 as smartphone prices continue to climb, making older models—many of which look and perform almost identically to their successors—an increasingly tempting option.
We recently asked our readers: which previous-generation phone would you choose over a brand-new 2026 model? The response was impressive, with more than 2,000 participants casting their votes. The results were tight, revealing clear favorites but also some surprises.
The Top Contenders
Our list of candidates included the Samsung Galaxy S25, Motorola Moto G Stylus 2025, Google Pixel 9a, Samsung Galaxy A56 5G, and Motorola Razr 2025. Each of these devices represents a strong value proposition, offering near-flagship features without the premium price tag of a 2026 flagship.
The Galaxy S25 emerged as the winner, securing 28.8% of the vote. This wasn’t a runaway victory, as the Google Pixel 9a trailed closely with 25.6%. The Samsung Galaxy A56 5G claimed 15.7%, while the Motorola Moto G Stylus 2025 and Motorola Razr 2025 received 14.6% and 9.2%, respectively. The remaining 6% of voters chose an alternative not listed in our poll.
Why the Galaxy S25 Topped the Chart
The Galaxy S25’s victory is hardly surprising. For Samsung loyalists, it offers a nearly identical experience to the Galaxy S26 at a significantly lower price point. The S25 retains the same refined design, excellent display, and capable camera system that made its successor a hit. With Samsung’s commitment to several years of software updates, buyers can enjoy a modern Android experience without breaking the bank.
Moreover, the S25 benefits from a mature software ecosystem. By the time it became an “older” model, many early bugs had been ironed out, and the device had received multiple security patches. For users who prioritize stability and reliability, this is a major advantage.
The Pixel 9a: A Strong Value Play
The Google Pixel 9a’s second-place finish highlights its reputation as one of the best value Android phones. It offers Google’s clean, fast software experience and some of the best camera processing in its price range. At about $200 cheaper than the Galaxy S26 on Amazon, the Pixel 9a provides a compelling alternative for budget-conscious buyers who still want top-tier photography and AI features.
Interestingly, the Pixel 9a is not much cheaper than the upcoming Pixel 10a, which makes it an even smarter choice for those who can wait for deals. Google’s update policy also ensures several years of OS and security updates, adding to the device’s longevity.
Surprises and Underdogs
One of the biggest surprises was the Motorola Razr 2025 lagging behind with only 9.2% of the vote. Despite earning praise for its foldable design and competitive pricing, it seems that many users still prefer the traditional slab form factor. Foldables remain a niche market, and even when they become more affordable, the durability concerns and higher repair costs may deter mainstream adoption.
The Galaxy A56 5G and Moto G Stylus 2025 also struggled to gain traction, perhaps because they are mid-range devices that don’t offer the premium feel or camera performance of the top two. However, for those on a tight budget, they remain solid choices.
Reader Suggestions: Going Off the Beaten Path
Our poll included an “Other” option, and many readers were eager to share their personal picks. Aidanleon99 argued in favor of the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra, stating it “does exactly what the average user needs for approximately 500 euros.” He added that you can “get 95% of what the S26 does for a fraction of the cost.” The S23 Ultra’s renowned camera system and S Pen functionality make it a favorite among power users who don’t need the latest chipset.
Others looked beyond mainstream brands. One reader snagged a “fab condition” HONOR Magic 6 Pro for 350 (presumably USD), while another imported a new Sony Xperia 5 IV from China for £323. These choices highlight a growing trend of seeking unique, high-spec devices from less dominant manufacturers, often at steep discounts.
The Resistance to Annual Upgrades
Not everyone in our poll embraced the idea of upgrading frequently. Rusty Harris voiced a sentiment shared by many: “Unless you have damaged your old phone, you don’t need to be upgrading every flipping year.” This perspective reinforces the core premise of our original article: buying a slightly older phone can be a smart financial and environmental decision.
Some readers also questioned the poll options themselves. A few suggested the OnePlus 13 as a worthy alternative, noting its fast charging and clean software. Others pointed out that the Galaxy S25 series doesn’t really feel old yet, which is a testament to how well recent flagships age. Indeed, the S25 was only released in early 2025, so it still feels current in 2026.
Broader Trends in the Used Phone Market
The survey results align with broader industry data. According to recent reports, the refurbished and used smartphone market is expected to grow by 10% annually through 2028. Consumers are increasingly aware that a two-year-old flagship can offer 90% of the performance of the latest model at half the price. This is particularly true for Android devices, where hardware improvements have plateaued in recent years.
Battery health remains a common concern, but many third-party retailers now offer certified refurbished models with new batteries and warranties. Additionally, manufacturers like Samsung and Google have extended their software support commitments, meaning older phones can now receive updates for five years or more.
Regional Variations
It’s worth noting that purchasing patterns vary by region. In markets like India and Southeast Asia, mid-range phones dominate, while in Europe and North America, there is a stronger preference for high-end flagships from Samsung and Google. The poll results likely reflect our predominantly Western readership, but similar surveys in other regions might show different winners.
For instance, the Motorola Moto G Stylus 2025, which received only 14.6% here, is a popular choice in Latin America due to its affordable price and built-in stylus. The Galaxy A56 5G, with its solid performance and large battery, is a strong seller in many emerging markets.
What This Means for Buyers
If you’re in the market for a phone in 2026, the message is clear: you don’t have to pay top dollar for a great experience. The Galaxy S25 and Pixel 9a are excellent representatives of their respective ecosystems, offering flagship-like performance at a discount. Even the Galaxy S23 Ultra remains a beast that can easily compete with newer models in terms of camera and productivity.
For those willing to explore alternatives, brands like HONOR, Sony, and OnePlus provide unique options that might better suit specific needs—whether it’s a headphone jack, expandable storage, or a telephoto camera. The key is to identify what matters most to you and then search for a slightly older device that excels in that area.
Ultimately, the survey reinforces a simple truth: the best phone is the one that meets your needs, not necessarily the newest one. As prices continue to rise, the value proposition of previous-generation devices will only become more compelling.
Thank you for being part of our community. We look forward to hearing your thoughts in the comments.
Source: Android Authority News